Situation Report 03.09.25

 Musicals!

    I chose the King and I to watch and... it was an interesting experience. On the one hand I could see what Rogers and Hammerstein were attempting to do by bringing the story of another culture into mainstream Broadway culture, and on a dramaturgical level the structure of the writing, and the musical theatre storytelling were both revolutionary for the time. The techniques they use to tell the story are tools that can still be seen in the musicals of today. Conversely the construct being supported by that writing is incredibly ignorant and misguided. While I do not claim to be an expert on Thai or, at that time, Siamese culture it is clear that the realization of Rogers and Hammerstein's vision lacked not only cultural sensitivity, but any sort of desire to include Thai voices in the creation of the piece. Moreover this musical's enduring cultural penetration seems to be based upon a White cultural love for a story that has historically excluded Asian artists from the storytelling.

    While I do not plan to use this writing to run down The King and I it would be dishonest to leave out the fact that watching the show was a bit of a slog for me. The article "Decompression in the King and I and KPOP" brought many of these frustrations to light. Learning about the disregard for accurate Thai dialects, and the ignoring of Thai cultural traditions in order to appeal to White audiences was insulting and frustrating to read. It makes me wonder if the King and I is a show that should be put on the shelf. The other concern is the thought that in order for there to be mainstream cultural penetration a work by a BIPOC or woman artist must pass through the lens of whiteness. KPOP's short Broadway run while King and I's revival wildly succeeded is a hard pill to swallow. It begs the question of why when it is time for authentic cultural representation there is always something in the way that handicaps that representation. Be it the pandemic, claims of not finding audiences, there is always an excuse for why accurate cultural representation cannot happen. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Situation Report 03.23.2025

Sit Rep 04.06.25

Sit Rep 04.27.2025